Near-death experiences: not as paranormal as they sound?
The quote above comes from a 48-year-old woman who, on one occasion, almost died from complications related to a spinal tumor; it evokes much of the general emotion associated with a classic near-death experience story.
The term “near-death experience” (NDE) is well-known throughout America, but the phenomenon is not restricted solely to the Western world. Most cultures have an equivalent experience; even children have related NDEs.
An NDE might involve walking toward a bright light at the end of a tunnel, meeting gods, speaking with relatives who are long-dead, out-of-body experiences (OBEs) or feeling bathed in light.
Almost unanimously a significant life experience, conversations about NDEs are often accompanied by discussions of the afterlife and the mind surviving the mortal body.
These kinds of esoteric tales would normally be banished to the realms of pseudoscience and parapsychology, but their pervasive nature – an estimated 3 percent of Americans report having experienced an NDE – has sparked a smattering of genuine scientific research and a wealth of conjecture.
What do NDEs consist of?
One Dutch study, published in The Lancet, set out to investigate the regularity of NDEs and tried to tease apart causal factors.
The investigators reported that 50 percent of individuals who experienced an NDE mentioned an awareness of being dead, 56 percent regarded it a positive experience, 24 percent reported an OBE, 31 percent described traveling through a tunnel and 32 percent spoke of interacting with deceased people.
The study also showed that, of the patients they interviewed, although all were clinically dead at one point, only a small percentage (18 percent) experienced, or remembered, the NDE. The likelihood of having an NDE was not related to the level of cerebral anoxia (lack of oxygen to the brain), the amount of preceding fear or the type of medication they were taking.
According to the paper, NDEs were more often experienced by patients under 60, and women more commonly described deeper experiences. Conversely, those with memory deficits following resuscitation were less likely to report NDEs, which is to be expected.
There is obviously something driving these experiences, but the factors that impact them are still very much up for debate.
Cultural flexibility in NDEs
The NDE phenomenon is particularly fascinating because the psychological and physiological factors are intimately tied to social and cultural factors. For instance, the NDE of a 40-year-old white male from Nebraska might include visions of a shimmering white, bearded male beckoning him through pearl-encrusted gates; the NDE of a 12-year-old boy from Papa New Guinea probably will not.
The Mapuche people of South America and residents of Hawaii are more likely to see landscapes and volcanoes, whereas NDEs in Thailand and India rarely involve landmarks, tunnels or light; for Tibetans, light features more heavily, as do illusions of reincarnation.
The following narrative comes from an African NDE, reported in 1992. A young man had been attacked by a lioness after attempting to capture one of her cubs:
“I could see myself going into some kind of a trance. A highway suddenly opened up before me. It seemed to be going endlessly into the sky. Along it were a lot of stars, also spreading up to the sky.
Each time I tried to get on the highway, the stars would block my way. I just stood there not knowing what to do. After a while, the highway and stars disappeared. I woke up and found myself in a hospital bed.”
Europeans and North Americans often visualize beautiful gardens; intriguingly, the Kalai of Melanesia are more inclined to see an industrialized world of factories.
Culture and a person’s hopes or dreams clearly influence the nature of NDEs; but what biological mechanisms could be behind this strange phenomenon?
What is behind NDEs?
A phenomenon so widely experienced cannot be dismissed as just another old wives’ tale, there has to be something biological at work to explain its prevalence.
Some observers claim that NDEs display a rift in current neuroscientific theory, and that the experience shows another, more esoteric facet to our existence.
Can neuroscience unpick the mysteries of the NDE?
Many believe we should split the mind from the functions of the brain, once and for all.
However, this type of thinking is not necessary to explain NDEs; rather than claiming paranormal origins, the field of cognitive neuroscience has attacked the problem as it would any other: as an output of the brain.
There are a few potential explanations, any number of which might be involved in each individual’s experience. The following are some attempts to explain the biological origin of NDEs.
The role of expectation
Expectation surely plays a part in the overall NDE; the differences between cultures mentioned above are testament to that. But expectation seems to play an even deeper role.
Interestingly, NDEs sometimes occur in people who were, in reality, nowhere near death, they just thought they were. One study that included 58 patients’ experiences of NDEs found that 30 were not, in fact, close to dying. However, there is more to an NDE than expectations, as we shall see.
OBEs are commonly a part of NDEs and sometimes include autoscopy – seeing one’s body from above. Although this seems like an otherworldly event, neuroscientists know that OBEs also happen in settings other than the near-deathbed.
For instance, during an attack of sleep paralysis, which affects up to 40 percent of people at some point in their lives, OBEs are common. Sleep paralysis occurs when an individual is still essentially in REM sleep, but their brain awakens partially.
During REM sleep, the brain effectively paralyzes the body to prevent it from acting out dreams. The brain, still believing that the person is asleep, keeps this lock on the body, subjecting the individual to a terrifying, literal, waking nightmare. The experience often involves a sensation of floating from one’s body and viewing the room from the ceiling’s perspective.
Other researchers have demonstrated that by stimulating the right temporoparietal junction (TPJ), they could induce OBEs artificially. The TPJ is a section of the brain that collates information from the thalamus (regulator of consciousness, sleep, and alertness), limbic system (involved in emotion, behavior, motivation, and long-term memory), and the senses.
So, regardless of how real the autoscopy feels, it can still be explained in neuroscientific terms.
Meeting the dead
Meeting and greeting the dead is another commonly reported aspect of NDEs and can be partially explained away by expectations. Cultures are often filled to the brim with tales of heaven or some other type of afterlife where long-dead relatives eagerly await us.
Added to this, people with Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s are known to have vivid hallucinations of ghost-like entities; some report seeing dead relatives in their homes. These types of apparitions have been linked to pallidotomy lesions – a kind of neurosurgery used in some Parkinson’s patients.
Ghostly apparitions are not necessarily rooted in another dimension.
The experiences are considered to be due to dysfunction in the pathways of dopamine, a neurotransmitter involved in the brain’s reward pathways that is known to cause hallucinations.
In truth, it is surprising that we do not hallucinate more than we already do. Our brains weave our senses into the experience of perception in such a way that we forget what a difficult and amazing job they do.
Any cracks in the perceptual sphere are seamlessly back-filled by the brain; as a quick example, we all have a blind spot where the optic nerve meets the retina. In this section of our visual field, we can see nothing at all, but we never notice because our brain simply fills in the blanks.
But on occasion, if under duress or when receiving confusing inputs, rather than penciling in a chair, a patch of wallpaper, or a door, it fills the void with a goblin or ghoul.
In macular degeneration, the center of the visual field gradually fails; patients report the hallucination of ghosts relatively frequently. This might be due to the brain attempting to make sense of the neural “noise” being generated from the faulty or partial messages it is receiving.
In short, a brain hallucinating at a time when it is receiving unusual signals, or not receiving appropriate signals, is not such a surprise.
Explaining the euphoria
Often, NDEs are reported as a euphoric, blissful experience. At first glance, this seems paradoxical, given the circumstances surrounding NDEs. However, a number of recreational drugs have been found to closely mimic the visual and emotional aspects of NDEs.
One such drug – ketamine – that is used both recreationally and as an anesthetic, can produce hallucinations, OBEs, euphoria, dissociation, and spiritual experiences. Ketamine produces these effects by acting at N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptors, the same receptors utilized by other recreational drugs, such as amphetamines.
When an animal is under extreme stress, dopamine and opioid pathways are known to trigger. These reward pathways seem to come into play during traumatic events; although we do not know exactly why this should be, they no doubt evolved to be of assistance in times of extreme danger.
A brain in shock, being flooded by natural opioids, can go some of the way to explaining the intense feelings of quiet and calm.
The tunnel of light
Possibly the most well-known facet of an NDE is the feeling of being drawn into a long tunnel with a bright light at the end. Some researchers believe that this phenomenon can be explained by retinal ischemia (lack of oxygen to the retina).
The theory goes that, as the retina is starved of oxygen, peripheral vision slowly decays and only the center of the visual field can be seen. Tunnel vision is a symptom of both extreme fear and oxygen loss (hypoxia), both of which are often present during the process of dying.
No doubt, NDEs are a complex phenomenon with a myriad of mechanisms behind them. From a lack of oxygen affecting the visual system to a brain struggling to make sense of strange emotions; from the drug-like triggering of reward pathways and a host of cultural expectations. Being close to death (or believing that you are) is a unique physiological and psychological experience. It is little wonder that it produces such a confusion of sights and sounds.
The precise nature of each NDE will not be unraveled for many years. After all, catching them in action, at one of the most critical points of an individual’s life is no easy task, and the ethics of experimental interventions could prove tricky.
One thing is for sure, NDEs are fascinating and are (probably) nothing to do with the afterlife. . . . or read the excellent book by Dr Eben Alexander – Proof of Heaven
AWARE—AWAreness during REsuscitation—A prospective study, Sam Parnia et al., Resuscitation, doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.resuscitation.2014.09.004, published December 2014, abstract.
Critical Thinking, Near death experiences: the dying brain, accessed 22 April 2016.
Features of “near-death experience” in relation to whether or not patients were near death, J. Owens et al., The Lancet, doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0140-6736(90)92780-L, published 10 November 1990, abstract.
Near-death experience in survivors of cardiac arrest: a prospective study in the Netherlands, Dr Pirn van Lommel et al., The Lancet, doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(01)07100-8 , published 15 December 2001, abstract.
Phenomenology of near-death experiences: a cross-cultural perspective, Belanti J et al., Transcultural Psychiatry, doi: 10.1177/1363461507088001, published March 2008, abstract.
Scientific American, Peace of mind: near-death experiences now found to have scientific explanations, accessed 22 April 2016.
Susanblackmore.co.uk, Coming close to death, accessed 22 April 2016.
The out-of-body experience: disturbed self-processing at the temporo-parietal junction, Blanke O et al., The Neuroscientist, doi: 10.1177/1073858404270885, published February 2005, abstract.
The physiology of the tunnel, Susan J. Blackmore et al., Journal of Near-Death Studies, doi: 10.1007/BF01076136, published September 1989, abstract.
There is nothing paranormal about near-death experiences: how neuroscience can explain seeing bright lights, meeting the dead, or being convinced you are one of them, Dean Mobbs et al., Trends in Cognitive Science, doi: 10.1016/j.tics.2011.07.010, published October 2011, abstract.